Skip to main content

On the Electoral College

With all due respect to the wisdom and genius of the Founding Fathers, I believe they got one thing wrong: the electoral college.

It is completely understandable.  I sometimes forget that there were no other democracies at the time; they were breaking new ground.  Whenever I hear politicians or pundits dodge hard questions by saying they don't want to engage in speculation, I think, "What cowardice."  The Founders had no maps, no manuals, no precedents to inform them other than the ancient Greeks, whose democracies were only for a small minority of the people, or the democratic principles practiced by some Native American tribes.

So, it is understandable that they were hesitant to turn over all the power to all the people.  Even today, I think if we're honest, not many of us are completely comfortable with 100% suffrage.  I know I've felt that democracy is good, but I'm a little nervous about "those guys" voting.  "Those guys" might be different guys for all of us, but I think, if we're honest, we all have some trepidation about "some guys".

And so, it seems to me, they came up with a democracy that was limited to those whom they thought would best be given the franchise to vote: white, male property owners.  And not only that, but they put in what they thought would be a hedge against the radicals even in that select group.  They created an electoral body that could overrule the popular vote in the case that the majority went off the rails and wanted to elect someone too far outside the bounds of rationality.

I am not a presidential historian, so I can only guess as to the qualifications of all of our presidents.  But if ever there was a candidate who was obviously unqualified, but extremely charismatic to enough voters, it would be Donald Trump. If ever there was a candidate who, if in spite of garnering the popular vote, should be disqualified by the one safeguard the Founders created, it would be Trump.

Yet, exactly the opposite happened.  The unruly, sometimes ignorant or disinterested public, which now included not only white male property owners, but all adults of all races and backgrounds, including women, voted against Trump, while the electoral college put him in office.

For various reasons that the Founders could not have imagined: the size of  the country, the diversity, the technology, the vast sums of money spent in elections today,  the Electoral College failed in its only duty, and, therefore, should be abolished.
                                       
PeteBarkett.blogspot.com
August 7, 2019

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

That's How the Light Gets In On Economic Perspective $Million per day My argument in today's blog is that the rich, especially the ultra-rich do not need protection from people advocating redistribution of wealth downward.   I'm recalling "Joe, the Plumber", (who was not named Joe and was not a plumber) who was used by a conservative Presidential candidate to exemplify that liberals would try to tax away the opportunity to start a business and become wealthy.  Also, I've been accused of being a conspiracy theorist when I've complained that the ultra-wealthy collude to protect and increase their massive wealth.    So, I'll address three issues at once: 1.  Are we trying to deprive the wealthy of their lifestyle? 2.  Do ultra-wealthy have the time, resources, and inclination to conspire to strongly influence politics and economics? 3.  To get an idea of economics in general, it helps to have an understanding of wealth. ...
1 comment
Read more
On Past Judgements Don't it always seem to go that you don't know what you've got til it's gone.  - Joni Mitchell In the 1976 Presidential election, I voted for John Anderson.  I was then, and still am, a liberal.  So, Gerald Ford was not a consideration, especially after he pardoned Nixon, which was unforgivable.  But I didn't trust Jimmy Carter, who claimed to be honest.  I didn't know much about the Southern Baptist Convention, but what I did know was that they opposed most everything that I supported.  Carter was a Southern Baptist, so Carter was out.  Four years later, I had changed my mind, and I enthusiastically supported Carter against Reagan, and over the years I grew to appreciate him more and more. Carter turned out to be much more honest and thoughtful than the average politician.   And he was open to change.  He recently left the Southern Baptist Convention after 60 years due to their belief that women should ...
Post a Comment
Read more
  The Trump Legend        What is the Trump story?   It will be quite different for followers and detractors.   I believe the reason that so many people can have completely opposite views of the same person and events lies in great part to our American, and perhaps human, myths.       I had occasion once to be watching a televangelist in the company of some fundamentalist in-laws.   Seeing this person crying while singing a hymn, I thought he was the phoniest person I had ever seen.   But one of my wife's aunts turned to me and said, "Isn't he the most sincere person you've ever seen?"   I didn't answer, but it occurred to me that we were sitting in the same room watching the same event with completely opposite views.   I love studying history, but I am now more careful to try and research the historian.       Some of us like to believe in heroic leaders following their ...
Post a Comment
Read more